Extended Holiday Hours - Check Google Maps For Store Hours
Extended Holiday Hours - Check Google Maps For Store Hours
Cart 0

Frequently Asked Questions

Do you offer free shipping?


We offer flat rate shipping of $9.95 on orders up to $99, as long as they're being shipped within the Lower 48 states (or D.C.). For more info on our shipping policies, check out our shipping page!

Do you ship internationally?


Sorry but we no longer offer international shipping.

Does Fishs Eddy sell gift cards?


Sorry but we no longer sell online gift cards.

If you have an existing in-store gift card you can place your order over the phone at 212-420-9020.

Gift card troubles?


Once you have added items to your shopping cart, view your shopping cart here. Then, enter your code in the appropriate fields and hit 'Apply'.

If your gift card code consists of only numbers (no letters or dashes) please call us at 212-420-9020 to place your order over the phone. (If this is the case, you've got an in-store card!)

Are all of your products available online?


We try our best to get our most popular items online. We have a lot of one-of-a-kind vintage pieces that are available in store only, so swing by and visit us at 889 Broadway at 19th Street in New York City! We're also always adding new items online, so subscribe to our mailing list for updates!

If I saw an item in your store but can't find it online, how can I purchase it?


Contact our store directly at 212-420-9020 to place an order over the phone and have it shipped to you.

Will you share my email address with other businesses?


No. Fishs Eddy respects the right to privacy.

Does Fishs Eddy have a wedding or gift registry?


Can items purchased online be returned to the store?


Yes, but please note only the cost of the items will be refunded, not the cost of shipping.